← All postsπŸ”Ž Better value?

Popular ETFs vs the alternatives: where you could pay less

The biggest ETFs got big by being first and best known, not always by being best value. For several of them, a near-identical fund costs less and has returned more. For others, the popular choice is still hard to beat.

Joshua Stega, financial adviser6 min readUpdated 9 November 2026
The short answer

For several of Australia's most popular ETFs, a near-identical fund costs less. BGBL charges 0.08% vs 0.18% for VGS, and PMGOLD 0.15% vs 0.40% for GOLD, with very similar returns. In a few cases the popular fund is still the better performer: VHY has beaten its cheaper rival over five years. Cheaper is a strong starting point, not the whole answer.

Many of Australia's biggest ETFs were the first in their category. They built a following when there was little competition, and money tends to stay put. Since then, rivals have launched funds that track the same or very similar markets for a lower fee.

When two funds hold the same things, the fee is the one difference you can count on, year after year. When they hold different things, returns can differ a lot, in either direction. We looked at eight matchups, using data to 31 October 2026.

0.41%a year saved, ETHI to VESG
$250a year saved per $100,000, GOLD to PMGOLD
7 of 8alternatives returned more

The fee gap

Fees

Popular fund vs alternative: annual fee

Popular fundAlternative
VAS vs A200Australian shares
0.07%
0.04%
VGS vs BGBLglobal shares
0.18%
0.08%
VGAD vs HGBLhedged global shares
0.21%
0.11%
GOLD vs PMGOLDgold
0.40%
0.15%
ETHI vs VESGethical global shares
0.59%
0.18%
VDHG vs DHHFall-in-one
0.27%
0.19%
VAP vs SLFAustralian property
0.23%
0.16%
VHY vs SYIAustralian high yield
0.25%
0.20%
Management fees (MER) at 31 October 2026. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.

The matchups, side by side

Popular fundSizeAlternativeFeesReturn (period)
VAS$27.0bnA2000.07% / 0.04%+38.7% / +41.7% (5Y)
VGS$18.6bnBGBL0.18% / 0.08%+65.6% / +67.8% (3Y)
VGAD$7.9bnHGBL0.21% / 0.11%+77.9% / +80.5% (3Y)
GOLD$5.4bnPMGOLD0.40% / 0.15%+134.2% / +137.8% (5Y)
VDHG$4.1bnDHHF0.27% / 0.19%+44.9% / +55.1% (5Y)
ETHI$3.8bnVESG0.59% / 0.18%+54.1% / +70.3% (5Y)
VAP$2.8bnSLF0.23% / 0.16%+12.8% / +11.9% (5Y)
VHY$8.4bnSYI0.25% / 0.20%+68.4% / +62.7% (5Y)

Cumulative total returns including distributions to 31 October 2026, over the longest period both funds have. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.

Who won

Alternative minus popular fund: return gap

β—€ Popular fund wonAlternative won β–Ά
ETHI / VESG5 years
+23.5 pts
VDHG / DHHF5 years
+10.4 pts
VGAD / HGBL3 years
+3.6 pts
VGS / BGBL3 years
+3.3 pts
VAS / A2005 years
+3.1 pts
GOLD / PMGOLD5 years
+2.9 pts
VAP / SLF5 years
+0.4 pts
VHY / SYI5 years
βˆ’5.3 pts
Percentage points of cumulative total return to 31 October 2026. Positive means the alternative returned more.

Where the alternative is close to a like-for-like swap

  • VAS to A200. The two overlap about 94%. A200 leaves out about 100 smaller companies and charges 0.03% less. Over five years it returned 3.1 points more. See VAS vs A200.
  • VGS to BGBL. Both hold large and mid-sized companies across developed markets outside Australia. BGBL charges less than half the fee and has edged ahead since it listed in 2023. See VGS vs BGBL.
  • VGAD to HGBL. The hedged versions of the same two funds, with the same 0.10% fee gap. See VGAD vs HGBL.
  • GOLD to PMGOLD. Both track the gold price, and returns are within 3 points over five years. PMGOLD, from the government-owned Perth Mint, charges 0.15%, as does Global X's own GXLD. On $100,000 that is $250 a year less than GOLD. See GOLD vs PMGOLD.
  • VAP to SLF. Both hold the big ASX-listed property trusts. SLF is 0.07% cheaper, with near-identical returns.
The one rule: if two funds hold the same market, choose on fee. If they hold different things, choose on what you want to own, then on fee.

Where the alternative is a different fund

  • ETHI vs VESG. This is the biggest gap. VESG returned 70.3% over five years against 54.1% for ETHI, at less than a third of the fee. But they overlap only about 27%. ETHI picks a smaller group of sustainability leaders and excludes more sectors; VESG screens a broad index. If ETHI's ethical rules matter to you, VESG is not a straight swap. See ETHI vs VESG and other ethical ETFs.
  • VDHG vs DHHF. DHHF returned 10.4 points more over five years and is cheaper, mainly because VDHG keeps about 10% in bonds. That is a choice about risk, not just cost. See VDHG vs DHHF.
$10,000 invested

What $10,000 grew to over five years

Popular fundAlternative
$13,872
$14,169
VAS / A200
$14,491
$15,515
VDHG / DHHF
$15,408
$17,029
ETHI / VESG
$16,843
$16,272
VHY / SYI
Value at 31 October 2026 with distributions reinvested, before tax and brokerage. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.
  • VHY vs SYI. SYI is cheaper at 0.20% and won over the past year (17.6% vs 12.0%), but VHY returned 5.7 points more over five years. They overlap only about 50%, because they pick high-yield shares differently. See VHY vs SYI.
  • IVV. At 0.04% it is already one of the cheapest funds on the ASX. Vanguard's VTS charges 0.03% for the whole US market, a difference too small to justify switching. See IVV vs VTS.
  • NDQ vs FANG. FANG is cheaper (0.35% vs 0.48%) and returned 131.7% over five years against 92.4% for NDQ. But it holds just ten companies, and it lost 4.4% over the past year against +3.4% for NDQ. It is a far more concentrated bet, not a cheaper version. See NDQ vs FANG.

Should you switch?

Fee saving

Annual fee saved on $100,000 by switching

ETHI to VESG
$410
GOLD to PMGOLD
$250
VGS to BGBL
$100
VGAD to HGBL
$100
VDHG to DHHF
$80
VAP to SLF
$70
VAS to A200
$30
Difference in management fee on $100,000 for one year. Excludes tax, brokerage and trading spreads.
  • New money is the easy case. There is no tax cost, so the lower fee simply starts working.
  • Existing holdings are harder. Selling can trigger capital gains tax, and on a large gain the bill can outweigh many years of savings. Holdings over 12 months get a 50% capital gains discount for individuals, but the tax is still real.
  • SMSFs in pension phase may pay no tax on gains, which makes switching much cheaper. Check your own position with your accountant.
  • Size and liquidity. Most alternatives here manage hundreds of millions or billions and trade with tight spreads, so size is rarely a reason to stay put.

Browse the cheapest ETF in every category β†’ or see the largest ETFs in Australia.

Common questions

Is there a cheaper alternative to VGS?

Yes. BGBL charges 0.08% against 0.18% for VGS, holds very similar companies, and returned 67.8% over three years to 31 October 2026 against 65.6% for VGS.

Is PMGOLD better than GOLD?

Both track the gold price and returned within 3 points of each other over five years. PMGOLD charges 0.15% vs 0.40%, saving $250 a year on $100,000.

Should I sell VAS and buy A200?

For existing holdings it is often not worth it. The fee saving is $30 a year per $100,000, which capital gains tax and brokerage can easily outweigh. Some investors put new money into A200 instead.

Why has VESG beaten ETHI?

They hold quite different portfolios, overlapping about 27%. VESG screens a broad global index and holds more of the large technology companies that led markets, while ETHI picks a narrower set of sustainability leaders and charges a higher fee.

Joshua Stega

Joshua Stega is a financial adviser with 20 years' experience and the founder of ETF Adviser. He built ReviewETF to make every Australian ETF easy to find and compare.

General information only. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider the PDS and TMD before investing. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Data as at 31 October 2026.

Keep in touch with the markets

Get Joshua's weekly ETF research, trade alerts and the model portfolio. Free for 30 days.

Start your free trial

Keep reading