← All posts⚖️ Head to head

VAS vs A200 vs IOZ: which Australian shares ETF?

Australia's three most popular share ETFs hold almost the same companies. So does it matter which one you pick? Here are the real numbers on fees, returns and overlap, and a simple way to decide.

Joshua Stega, financial adviser5 min readUpdated 11 November 2026
The short answer

VAS, A200 and IOZ are about 91 to 95% the same. Over five years their returns are within 0.4% a year of each other. A200 is the cheapest at 0.04% a year, VAS holds about 100 extra smaller companies, and IOZ sits in between. Pick one, keep it, and don't hold two of them.

Why these three ETFs matter

If you own Australian shares through an ETF, there is a good chance it is one of these. Together VAS, A200 and IOZ manage about $47 billion, and they were three of the five most popular ETFs in Australia in September, taking in more than $1 billion of new money between them in a single month.

They all do the same job: give you the biggest companies on the ASX in one trade, for a very low fee. The question most investors ask is whether one is meaningfully better than the others.

$26.7bnVAS, Australia's largest ETF
0.04%A200 fee, the lowest of the three
94%overlap between VAS and A200

The side-by-side numbers

Head to head

VAS vs A200 vs IOZ vs STW at a glance

VASA200IOZSTW
Management feelower is cheaper
0.07%
0.04%
0.05%
0.05%
Fund size$ billions
$26.7bn
$11.1bn
$9.7bn
$6.5bn
Companies heldapproximate
300
200
200
200
5-year returnper year
6.5%
6.9%
6.8%
6.7%
Fees, fund size and total returns to 30 September 2026. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.
VASA200IOZSTW
IssuerVanguardBetasharesiSharesState Street
IndexS&P/ASX 300Solactive Australia 200S&P/ASX 200S&P/ASX 200
Companies heldabout 300about 200about 200about 200
Fee (MER)0.07%0.04%0.05%0.05%
Fund size$26.7bn$11.1bn$9.7bn$6.5bn
1-year return+2.2%+2.9%+2.6%+2.6%
3-year return (a year)+10.8%+11.0%+10.8%+11.0%
5-year return (a year)+6.5%+6.9%+6.8%+6.7%
Listed2009201820102001

Total returns including distributions to 30 September 2026. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.

$10,000 invested

What $10,000 grew to

VASA200IOZSTW
$10,223
$10,286
$10,262
$10,261
1 year ago
$13,603
$13,679
$13,601
$13,669
3 years ago
$13,672
$13,985
$13,895
$13,821
5 years ago
Value at 30 September 2026 with distributions reinvested, before tax and brokerage. The bars are close because these funds are nearly identical.

The gap between the best and worst over five years is about 0.4% a year. On $100,000 that is roughly $2,700 over five years. It is real money, but it is small next to the swings of the share market itself.

Why A200 has edged ahead

Two things explain most of the difference.

  • Fees. A200 charges 0.04% a year, VAS 0.07%. On $100,000 that is $40 vs $70 a year. Small, but it compounds every year.
  • Small companies. VAS holds the ASX 300, so it owns about 100 smaller companies the others leave out. Over the last few years large companies have done better than small ones, so that extra slice has held VAS back slightly. In a year when small companies lead, it would help.
Fees over time

What fees cost on $100,000 over 20 years

VAS0.07% a year
$5,032
IOZ0.05% a year
$3,601
STW0.05% a year
$3,601
A2000.04% a year
$2,883
Illustrative: $100,000 growing at 7% a year before fees for 20 years. The difference is the return given up to fees.
The one rule: the index matters more than the issuer. ASX 200 funds (A200, IOZ, STW) will track each other almost exactly. VAS will differ a little because of its smaller companies.

How much do they overlap?

Using each issuer's published holdings, the overlap is very high:

PairOverlapWhat it means
A200 and IOZ95%Practically the same fund
VAS and A20094%Holding both adds almost nothing
VAS and IOZ91%Holding both adds almost nothing
Overlap

How much of each pair is the same

A200 and IOZ
95%
VAS and A200
94%
VAS and IOZ
91%
Overlap counts the smaller weight of every company held by both funds. Issuer holdings at 30 September to 30 October 2026.

All three have the same top five: BHP, Commonwealth Bank, NAB, Westpac and ANZ, together about 33 to 36% of each fund. Banks and miners make up more than half of every one. That is the Australian share market, not a quirk of any ETF.

Inside the funds

The same five companies make up a third of each fund

BHPCBANABWestpacANZEverything else
VAS
11%9%67%
A200
11%10%5%5%5%64%
IOZ
11%10%5%5%5%65%
STW
11%10%5%5%5%65%
Weights from each issuer's published holdings. Tap a company name in any holdings table on ReviewETF to see every ETF that owns it.

Check the overlap yourself in our overlap calculator →

So which one should you choose?

  • Choose A200 if you want the lowest fee and are happy with the top 200 companies.
  • Choose VAS if you want the broadest coverage, including smaller companies, and like Vanguard's size. It is Australia's largest ETF.
  • Choose IOZ if you already use iShares for your international ETFs and want everything with one issuer.
  • Already own one? Switching usually isn't worth it. Selling can trigger capital gains tax and brokerage, which can easily cost more than years of fee savings.

Whichever you pick, it is a core holding. Most investors pair it with a global shares ETF, because Australia is only about 2% of the world's share market. See VGS vs IVV for the global side.

Common questions

Is VAS or A200 better?

Over five years A200 has returned slightly more (6.9% a year vs 6.5%), mainly because of its lower fee and because it leaves out smaller companies, which lagged. Both are excellent low-cost core funds and they are 94% the same.

Should I own VAS and A200 together?

Usually no. They are 94% the same, so you pay two fees for one portfolio and add complexity without adding diversification.

Do they pay franked distributions?

Yes. All three pay distributions, usually quarterly, with a large share of franking credits because they own Australian companies that pay franked dividends.

Joshua Stega

Joshua Stega is a financial adviser with 20 years' experience and the founder of ETF Adviser. He built ReviewETF to make every Australian ETF easy to find and compare.

General information only. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider the PDS and TMD before investing. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Data as at 30 September 2026.

Keep in touch with the markets

Get Joshua's weekly ETF research, trade alerts and the model portfolio. Free for 30 days.

Start your free trial

Keep reading