In the core funds, Betashares has become the cheaper choice: A200, BGBL, HGBL and DHHF all charge less than their Vanguard rivals and have returned slightly more over three years. Vanguard wins on size and income: it manages $108 billion, and VHY has beaten Betashares' HVST by 37 percentage points over five years. The gaps in the core pairs are small, so switching rarely pays.
The two issuers in one minute
Vanguard is the American firm that made index investing mainstream. Its Australian line-up is small and focused: 37 ETFs, almost all broad, low-cost index funds. It runs the two biggest ETFs in the country, VAS and VGS.
Betashares is Australian, founded in 2009. It took the opposite path: 109 ETFs covering everything from plain market funds to the Nasdaq, cybersecurity, cash, bonds and geared funds. Its core funds have been priced to undercut Vanguard.
Vanguard vs Betashares at a glance
Vanguard's average fee is lower because almost all its money sits in cheap index funds. Betashares' average is pulled up by its thematic and active funds. Fund by fund, though, Betashares is often the cheaper option, as the six rounds show.
Round 1: Australian shares, VAS vs A200
VAS holds about 300 Australian companies for 0.07% a year. A200 holds the top 200 for 0.04%. They are 94% the same. Over five years A200 returned 6.9% a year against 6.5% for VAS, helped by its lower fee and by leaving out smaller companies, which lagged. Winner: A200 on cost, by a whisker. Our full breakdown is in VAS vs A200 vs IOZ.
Round 2: global shares, VGS vs BGBL
Both hold the big companies of the developed world outside Australia: Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft, Alphabet and Amazon at the top. VGS charges 0.18%, BGBL 0.08%. They use different index providers, so the overlap is 76% rather than near-total. Over three years BGBL returned 67.4% against 64.1% for VGS. VGS is more than three times the size at $18.7 billion and has a longer record. Winner: BGBL on fees. See VGS vs BGBL.
Round 3: hedged global shares, VGAD vs HGBL
The same story with the currency hedged out. VGAD charges 0.21%, HGBL 0.11%. Over three years HGBL returned 75.6% against 72.0%. Both gained about 17% last year as the Australian dollar rose. Winner: HGBL on fees. Compare them at VGAD vs HGBL.
Management fee in each matchup
Round 4: all-in-one, VDHG vs DHHF
These are single-fund portfolios. VDHG keeps about 10% in bonds and cash; DHHF is all shares. That difference, plus a lower fee (0.19% vs 0.27%), explains why DHHF has returned 9.2% a year over five years against 7.7% for VDHG. The flip side is that DHHF has no cushion when shares fall. Winner: DHHF on returns and cost, VDHG for a slightly smoother ride. More in VDHG vs DHHF vs GHHF.
Round 5: dividend income, VHY vs HVST
This is the one round that is not close. VHY is a simple index of high-yielding Australian companies for 0.25%, with $8.2 billion invested. HVST is an actively managed "dividend harvester" charging 0.72%, with $278 million. Over five years VHY returned 62.4%; HVST returned 24.9%. Both pay franked income, but VHY has delivered far more total return. Winner: VHY, clearly. See VHY vs HVST and our income ETF list.
Round 6: Asian shares, VAE vs ASIA
These do different jobs. VAE owns hundreds of Asian companies outside Japan for 0.40%. ASIA owns 50 Asian technology companies for 0.67%, with 85% in tech. Only 25% of their holdings overlap. The chip boom has made ASIA the big winner: up 124.8% over five years against 54.3% for VAE. That came with far more concentration in a handful of companies such as SK hynix, Samsung and TSMC. Winner: ASIA on returns, VAE on breadth and cost. Compare at ASIA vs VAE.
Three-year return gap in each matchup
What $10,000 grew to over three years
Is one issuer safer than the other?
Both are large, regulated Australian fund managers. Your ETF's assets are held by an independent custodian, separate from the issuer's own balance sheet, so the issuer's size is not what protects you. What differs is philosophy:
- Vanguard suits investors who want a short list of broad funds, a long track record and very deep trading in the biggest names.
- Betashares suits investors who want the lowest fee on core exposure, or who want themes and tools Vanguard does not offer.
- Mixing them is fine. Many portfolios hold A200 for Australia and VGS for the world, or VAS with BGBL. What matters is not doubling up: VAS plus A200 is one fund paid for twice.
The verdict
On the scorecard, Betashares takes four rounds (Australian shares, global, hedged global, all-in-one) on cost, Vanguard takes income, and Asia depends on whether you want breadth or a technology bet. If you already own the Vanguard fund in a core pair, the fee saving is usually 0.03% to 0.10% a year. On $200,000 that is $60 to $200 a year, which can easily be wiped out by capital gains tax and brokerage if you sell to switch. New money is a different matter: it is a fair time to compare.
Compare all four side by side → or browse the full Vanguard and Betashares ranges.
Common questions
Is Vanguard or Betashares better for ETFs?
Neither is better across the board. Betashares has the cheaper fund in four of the six core matchups we tested, while Vanguard is larger and its VHY has clearly beaten Betashares' HVST for income. Choose fund by fund.
Should I switch from VAS to A200 or VGS to BGBL?
Usually only with new money. Selling an existing holding can trigger capital gains tax and brokerage, which can cost more than years of the fee saving. Many investors simply direct future contributions to the cheaper fund.
Is my money safe if an ETF issuer runs into trouble?
ETF assets are held by a separate custodian in trust for investors, not on the issuer's balance sheet. That applies to both Vanguard and Betashares.
Can I hold Vanguard and Betashares ETFs together?
Yes. Mixing issuers is common and sensible. Just avoid holding two funds that do the same job, such as VAS and A200, or VGS and BGBL.

Joshua Stega is a financial adviser with 20 years' experience and the founder of ETF Adviser. He built ReviewETF to make every Australian ETF easy to find and compare.
General information only. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider the PDS and TMD before investing. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Data as at 30 September 2026.