← All posts🧪 We tested it

Is the cheapest ETF always the best? We tested 16 categories

Buy the cheapest fund is the most common ETF advice in Australia. We put it to the test in 16 groups of similar funds. The answer depends on one thing: whether the funds track the same index.

Joshua Stega, financial adviser6 min readUpdated 9 November 2026▶ Includes video
The short answer

The cheapest ETF had the best return in 8 of 16 like-for-like groups. When funds track the same or a near-identical index, such as A200 vs IOZ or PMGOLD vs GOLD, the cheapest won or tied almost every time. When the index differed, the index mattered far more than the fee: in emerging markets the cheapest fund trailed the best by 8.9% a year.

How we ran the test

We grouped ETFs that do the same job, such as Australian shares, the S&P 500 or physical gold, and compared the fund with the lowest fee (MER, the yearly management cost) against the others in its group.

  • Returns are total returns after fees, including distributions, to 30 September 2026, shown per year.
  • Five years where funds have that record, otherwise three years (marked).
  • Ties on fee go to the larger fund.
8 of 16groups where the cheapest fund won
8.9 ptsa year: the biggest gap, in emerging markets
0.04%A200 and IVV, cheapest and best in their groups

The results, group by group

GroupCheapestBest performerGap
Australian shares (ASX 200/300)A200 0.04%, 6.9%A200Cheapest won
S&P 500IVV 0.04%, 13.4%IVVCheapest won
Physical goldPMGOLD 0.15%, 19.9%PMGOLDCheapest won
Australian bondsVAF 0.10%, -0.1%VAFCheapest won
All-in-one high growthDHHF 0.19%, 9.2%DHHFCheapest won
Australian small companiesVSO 0.30%, 4.8%VSOCheapest won
Global infrastructure, hedged (3y)GLIN 0.15%, 12.3%GLINCheapest won
Global shares, ESGIWLD 0.09%, 12.3%IWLDCheapest won
CashBILL 0.07%, 3.1%ISEC 0.12%, 3.2%+0.1 pts
Australian propertySLF 0.16%, 2.4%MVA 0.35%, 2.5%+0.1 pts
Australian high dividendSYI 0.20%, 9.5%VHY 0.25%, 10.2%+0.7 pts
US sharesVTS 0.03%, 12.4%IVV 0.04%, 13.4%+1.1 pts
Global shares (3y)WXOZ 0.07%, 16.9%BGBL 0.08%, 18.7%+1.8 pts
Global shares, hedged (3y)WXHG 0.10%, 18.6%HGBL 0.11%, 20.6%+2.1 pts
Global qualityQLTY 0.35%, 9.2%QUAL 0.40%, 11.4%+2.2 pts
Emerging marketsVGE 0.48%, 5.8%EMKT 0.69%, 14.7%+8.9 pts

Fee, then total return a year: 5 years to 30 September 2026 unless marked 3y. Gap is the best performer's yearly return minus the cheapest fund's. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.

Who won

Best rival minus the cheapest fund, points a year

◀ Cheapest wonA pricier fund won ▶
All-in-oneDHHF vs VDHG
−1.5
ESG globalIWLD vs VESG
−0.6
S&P 500IVV vs SPY
−0.5
GoldPMGOLD vs GOLD
−0.3
ASX 200A200 vs IOZ
−0.1
CashBILL vs ISEC
+0.1
DividendSYI vs VHY
+0.7
US sharesVTS vs IVV
+1.1
Global (3y)WXOZ vs BGBL
+1.8
QualityQLTY vs QUAL
+2.2
EmergingVGE vs EMKT
+8.9
Total returns a year to 30 September 2026, 5 years unless marked. Negative: the cheapest fund beat its best rival by that much. Source: TMX Australia.

Where cheapest wins: same index, same holdings

When two funds hold essentially the same things, there is nowhere for a difference in return to come from except costs. Every bit of fee comes straight off your return.

  • Australian shares. A200 (0.04%), IOZ (0.05%), STW (0.05%) and VAS (0.07%) finished in exact fee order over five years: 6.9%, 6.8%, 6.7% and 6.5% a year.
  • S&P 500. IVV at 0.04% beat SPY at 0.09% by 0.5 points a year. That is more than the 0.05-point fee gap. SPY is a US-domiciled fund quoted on the ASX, and its structure and tax treatment can add to the difference.
  • Physical gold. PMGOLD (0.15%) and GOLD (0.40%) hold the same metal. PMGOLD came out 0.3 points a year ahead, roughly the fee gap.
Same index, different fee

Five-year return a year, in fee order

CheapestNextDearest
6.9%
6.8%
6.5%
A200 / IOZ / VAS
13.4%
12.9%
–
IVV / SPY
19.9%
19.6%
–
PMGOLD / GOLD
5-year total returns a year to 30 September 2026. Fees: A200 0.04%, IOZ 0.05%, VAS 0.07%; IVV 0.04%, SPY 0.09%; PMGOLD 0.15%, GOLD 0.40%.
The one rule: choose the index first, then the cheapest fund that tracks it. Fee only decides the winner once the index is the same.

Where cheapest loses: the index is different

Every big loss for the cheapest fund came from a group where the funds track different indexes. The fee gap was tiny; the index gap was not.

  • US shares. VTS (0.03%) holds the whole US market, including thousands of mid and small companies. IVV (0.04%) holds only the 500 largest. Large companies led, so IVV won by 1.1 points a year. See IVV vs VTS.
  • Global shares. WXOZ (0.07%) uses a carbon-aware version of the world index, which tilts away from some companies. Over three years it trailed BGBL (0.08%) by 1.8 points a year. See VGS vs BGBL.
  • Global quality. QUAL and QLTY both chase quality companies, but with different rules. QUAL holds about 300 companies, QLTY about 150. QUAL won by 2.2 points a year. See QUAL vs QLTY.
  • Emerging markets. EMKT uses a multi-factor approach and returned 14.7% a year, against 5.8% for VGE and 8.2% for IEM. Its holdings and country weights are very different from a plain market index. See VGE vs EMKT.
Emerging markets

Fee vs 5-year return in emerging markets

Fee5-year return a year
VGEVanguard, FTSE index
0.48%
5.80%
IEMiShares, MSCI index
0.69%
8.20%
EMKTVanEck, multi-factor
0.69%
14.70%
Fee (MER) and 5-year total return a year to 30 September 2026. Each row is scaled on its own. Source: TMX Australia.

A different index is a bet, and bets can go either way. A strong five years for one approach is no promise of the next five. The point is simply that index choice moved returns by far more than any fee did.

Close calls that are really ties

In cash and Australian property, the cheapest fund lost by about 0.1 points a year. That is within normal noise. Cash ETFs such as AAA and ISEC hold bank deposits and short-term securities that can earn a touch more than BILL, which roughly offsets their higher fee. In practice these funds are interchangeable.

What the fee still costs you

Even when the cheapest fund lost, the fee kept working against every fund in the group. Over long periods, small differences add up.

Fees over time

What the fee costs on $100,000 over 20 years

0.04%A200, IVV
$2,883
0.18%VGS
$12,814
0.40%QUAL, GOLD
$27,927
0.69%IEM, EMKT
$46,966
Illustrative: $100,000 growing at 7% a year before fees for 20 years. The bar is the return given up to fees. Not a forecast.
  • Same index? Pick the cheapest large fund. There is no reason to pay more for the same thing.
  • Different index? Understand what each one holds first. A higher fee can be worth it if you want that specific approach, but it has to earn its cost.
  • Already own a pricier version? Selling can trigger capital gains tax and brokerage, which can outweigh years of fee savings.

See every low-cost ETF on the ASX →

Common questions

Is the cheapest ETF always the best?

Not always. In our test the cheapest fund won in 8 of 16 groups. It reliably wins when funds track the same index, but when the index differs, the index usually matters more than the fee.

What is the cheapest ETF in Australia?

VTS, which tracks the whole US share market, charges 0.03% a year. A200 and IVV are next at 0.04%.

Is A200 better than VAS because it is cheaper?

Over five years A200 returned 6.9% a year and VAS 6.5%. About 0.03 points of that is the fee; the rest is mostly because VAS also holds about 100 smaller companies, which lagged.

Are higher-fee ETFs ever worth it?

Sometimes, if they track a genuinely different index or strategy you want, such as a quality or multi-factor approach. Judge them on what they hold and their long-term record, not the fee alone.

Joshua Stega

Joshua Stega is a financial adviser with 20 years' experience and the founder of ETF Adviser. He built ReviewETF to make every Australian ETF easy to find and compare.

General information only. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider the PDS and TMD before investing. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Data as at 30 September 2026.

Keep in touch with the markets

Get Joshua's weekly ETF research, trade alerts and the model portfolio. Free for 30 days.

Start your free trial

Keep reading