← All posts🧩 Portfolio overlap

How many ETFs should you hold? The overlap data

Many Australian portfolios hold four or five ETFs that own the same 20 companies. We measured the real overlap between the most popular funds. The answer to how many you need depends on whether the next fund adds anything new.

Joshua Stega, financial adviser6 min readUpdated 10 November 2026▶ Includes video
The short answer

For the core, fewer is better: one all-in-one ETF, or two to four broad funds that cover different markets. Popular Australian share ETFs overlap by 91 to 95%, so a second one adds almost nothing. Satellites are different: a semiconductor, gold miner or Asian tech ETF overlaps with a fund like DHHF by only 1 to 9%, so each one genuinely adds something. The right number is however many funds are genuinely different.

More ETFs is not more diversification

Diversification means owning things that behave differently. Owning more tickers does not do that if the tickers hold the same companies. To measure it, we use overlap: for every company two funds both own, we take the smaller of the two weights and add them up. 100% means identical funds; 0% means nothing in common.

Here is what the data shows for the pairs Australians most often hold together.

Overlap

Pairs that mostly duplicate each other

A200 and IOZASX 200 vs ASX 200
95%
VAS and A200ASX 300 vs ASX 200
94%
VAS and IOZASX 300 vs ASX 200
91%
VAS and STWASX 300 vs ASX 200
90%
IVV and VTSS&P 500 vs US total market
88%
A200 and VHYindex vs high dividend
68%
VGS and IVVdeveloped world vs S&P 500
65%
True holdings overlap from each issuer's published holdings, September and October 2026. For the broadest global funds, very small positions are not all included, so their true overlap may be a little higher.

Holding VAS, A200 and IOZ together is the most common mistake we see. It is the same portfolio three times, with three fees and three lots of paperwork.

The same five companies, four times over

Take a portfolio of VAS, A200, IOZ and VHY. It looks like four funds. Underneath, BHP and the big four banks make up about a third of every one.

Inside the funds

BHP and the big four banks in four popular ETFs

BHPCBANABWestpacANZEverything else
VAS
11%9%67%
A200
11%10%5%5%5%64%
IOZ
11%10%5%5%5%65%
VHY
10%9%6%6%6%62%
Weights from each issuer's published holdings, September and October 2026.

The global side has the same issue. VGS, IVV, NDQ and BGBL all lead with Apple, NVIDIA, Microsoft, Alphabet and Amazon. Those five are 22 to 32% of each fund.

Inside the funds

Five US giants lead every global share ETF

AppleNVIDIAMicrosoftAlphabetAmazonEverything else
VGS
5%6%78%
BGBL
6%6%78%
IVV
8%8%6%4%71%
NDQ
8%8%6%5%68%
Weights from each issuer's published holdings, September and October 2026.

See the overlap in your own portfolio →

What real diversification looks like

The pairs that genuinely spread your money are ones that fish in different ponds.

  • VAS and VGS: 0% overlap. Australia and the developed world have no companies in common. This is the single biggest diversification step most investors can take, because Australia is only about 2% of the world share market.
  • VGS and VGE: 0% overlap. Emerging markets add thousands of companies VGS does not own.
  • VGS and VEU: 16% overlap. VEU leaves out the US, so it adds weight to Europe, Japan and emerging markets.
Overlap

Pairs that genuinely diversify

VAS and VGSAustralia vs the world
0%
VGS and VGEdeveloped vs emerging
0%
VGS and VEUworld vs world ex-US
16%
VGS and NDQworld vs Nasdaq 100
40%
VGS and IVVworld vs S&P 500
65%
True holdings overlap from issuer holdings, September and October 2026. Lower means more genuinely different.

One fund or build it yourself?

For the core, there are two good answers.

  • One all-in-one ETF. DHHF (0.19%, 100% growth), VDHG (0.27%, 90% growth) or VDGR (0.27%, 70% growth) hold Australian, global and emerging market shares, and bonds where relevant, in one fund that rebalances itself. Over five years to 30 September 2026, DHHF returned 9.2% a year and VDHG 7.7%.
  • Two to four broad funds. An Australian index fund, a global fund and perhaps emerging markets or bonds. Fees can be lower, but you rebalance yourself.

What does not work is mixing the two. DHHF already holds about 37% of what VAS holds and 40% of VGS. Adding them on top just shifts the weights around. DHHF and VDHG together overlap by 64%. See VDHG vs DHHF or VGS vs DHHF.

The one rule: if two funds overlap by more than about 60%, you probably only need one of them. Check before you buy.

Where more ETFs can help: satellites

Broad index funds are weighted by company size, so they hold almost nothing in smaller themes. That is where satellites come in. Against DHHF, a typical one-fund core, the overlap is tiny:

Satellites vs the core

How much each satellite overlaps with DHHF

IKOSouth Korea
0.7%
ASIAAsian tech
1.1%
GDXgold miners
1.8%
ATOMuranium
2.3%
WIREcopper miners
4.4%
SEMIsemiconductors
8.6%
NDQNasdaq 100
21.0%
True holdings overlap with DHHF from issuer holdings, September and October 2026.

So in the satellite sleeve, each new ETF really does add something. SEMI, GDX, ASIA and WIRE each give you exposure the core barely touches. NDQ is a weaker satellite, because a fifth of it is already in DHHF.

Why the satellite is hard

Low overlap cuts both ways. Satellites move on their own, so the spread between winners and losers is huge. In the 12 months to 30 September 2026:

Last 12 months

Satellite ETFs: the best and the worst

◀ LostGained ▶
IKOSouth Korea
+125.3
SEMIsemiconductors
+109.0
ASIAAsian tech
+55.4
WIREcopper miners
+38.1
DFNDdefence
−15.4
NDIAIndia
−17.2
ATOMuranium
−18.9
QBTCbitcoin
−31.1
1-year total returns to 30 September 2026. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.

Picking themes, and getting in and out at sensible times, takes work. ETF Adviser's approach is to follow the trend: buy a theme as a new uptrend forms and step aside when it breaks. Satellites also cost more, often 0.45 to 0.70% a year, and some are small with wider trading spreads. That is why they work best as small positions, each sized so a failure cannot do serious damage.

So how many ETFs should you own?

  • Core: one all-in-one fund, or two to four broad funds that do not overlap much. Many investors keep most of their money here.
  • Satellites: optional. Investors who use them often hold a handful, each small, chosen because it adds something the core lacks.
  • Too many is any fund that mostly repeats one you already own.

Run your current list through the overlap calculator, or read our guides to the core and satellite portfolios and the ETF concentration problem.

Check your global funds for overlap →

Common questions

How many ETFs should I have in my portfolio?

Most investors can cover the core with one diversified ETF or two to four broad funds. Any extra fund should own something genuinely different, which in practice means satellites such as sector, region or commodity ETFs.

Is it bad to own VAS and A200 together?

It is not harmful, but it is pointless. They overlap by about 94%, so you pay two fees and keep two sets of records for what is effectively one portfolio.

Does VGS overlap with IVV?

Yes, by about 65%. IVV is the 500 largest US companies, and the US is the largest part of VGS. Holding both mainly increases your weight in US shares.

How do I check ETF overlap?

Use the ReviewETF overlap calculator. Enter two or more ETF codes and it compares their published holdings company by company.

Joshua Stega

Joshua Stega is a financial adviser with 20 years' experience and the founder of ETF Adviser. He built ReviewETF to make every Australian ETF easy to find and compare.

General information only. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider the PDS and TMD before investing. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Data as at 30 September 2026.

Keep in touch with the markets

Get Joshua's weekly ETF research, trade alerts and the model portfolio. Free for 30 days.

Start your free trial

Keep reading