← All posts🧭 ETF explained

ETFs vs index funds vs managed funds: which is best?

An ETF, an index fund and a managed fund can hold exactly the same shares. What differs is how you buy them, what you pay, and who decides what goes in. Those differences can add up to tens of thousands of dollars.

Joshua Stega, financial adviser6 min readUpdated 11 November 2026
The short answer

"Index or active" matters more than "ETF or managed fund". An index fund simply tracks a market; a managed fund usually has a manager picking investments. An ETF is a fund you buy on the stock exchange, and it can be either. Index ETFs are now the cheapest option for most people, with core funds like A200 and IVV at 0.04% a year, against a median 0.70% for active ETFs.

Three terms, explained simply

These words get used loosely, so it helps to separate two questions: how is the fund run, and how do you buy it?

  • Managed fund. A pooled fund run by a professional manager. Traditionally it is unlisted: you apply through the fund manager or a platform, and units are priced once a day. Most managed funds are actively managed, meaning the manager picks the investments.
  • Index fund. A fund that follows an index, such as the ASX 200, and holds every company in it. Nobody picks shares, which keeps costs low. Index funds can be unlisted managed funds or ETFs.
  • ETF (exchange traded fund). A fund whose units trade on the ASX or TMX like shares. You buy and sell through a broker during market hours. Most ETFs are index funds, but there are now 156 active ETFs too.
The one rule: the wrapper (ETF or unlisted fund) affects convenience. The strategy (index or active) and the fee drive your long-term return.

How they compare

Unlisted managed fundUnlisted index fundIndex ETFActive ETF
Who decides holdingsFund managerIndex rulesIndex rulesFund manager
How you buyApplication to manager or platformApplication to manager or platformAny broker, on the exchangeAny broker, on the exchange
PriceOnce a dayOnce a dayLive during trading hoursLive during trading hours
MinimumSet by the fund, often thousandsSet by the fund$500 first trade on the ASX$500 first trade on the ASX
Holdings disclosedUsually periodicallyIndex is publicUsually dailyVaries by fund
Typical fee levelHigherLowLowest: from 0.03%Median 0.70%
BrokerageNone, but may have buy/sell spreadsNone, but may have buy/sell spreadsYes, per tradeYes, per trade

ETF fee data at 31 October 2026. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report. Unlisted fund features vary by product; check each fund's disclosure document.

The real difference: cost

Fees come out of your balance every year, whatever the market does. The gap between a cheap index fund and an active fund looks small as a percentage, but it compounds.

Fees over time

What fees cost on $100,000 over 20 years

0.04% a yeare.g. A200, IVV
$2,883
0.18% a yeare.g. VGS
$12,814
0.70% a yearmedian active ETF
$47,605
1.00% a year38 active ETFs charge 1% or more
$66,255
1.50% a yearillustration
$95,193
Illustrative: $100,000 growing at 7% a year before fees for 20 years. The difference is the return given up to fees. Not a forecast.

On $100,000 over 20 years, a 0.04% fund costs under $3,000 in lost growth. A 1% fund costs about $66,000. For a retiree with $500,000 invested, that difference runs well into six figures.

Today's fees

Fees on popular index and active ETFs

VTSUS total market, index
0.03%
A200Australian shares, index
0.04%
IVVUS S&P 500, index
0.04%
VASAustralian shares, index
0.07%
BGBLglobal shares, index
0.08%
VGSglobal shares, index
0.18%
HYGGglobal growth, active
0.70%
AASFAustralian shares, active
0.78%
Management fees (MER) at 31 October 2026. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.

Does paying more buy better results?

Usually not. We compared every active ETF with a five-year record against a cheap index ETF. None of the nine active Australian share ETFs beat A200, and only two of 15 active global share ETFs beat VGS.

$10,000 invested

Five years: index ETF vs the median active ETF

Index ETFMedian active ETF
$13,985
$12,089
Australian shares
$17,457
$13,763
Global shares
Value at 31 October 2026 with distributions reinvested. Index ETF is A200 for Australian shares and VGS for global shares. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.

Many active ETFs are simply a listed version of an existing managed fund, often with "Fund" and "Active ETF" in the name, such as AASF (Airlie Australian Share Fund) and HYGG (Hyperion Global Growth Companies Fund). Same manager, same strategy, a different way in. The listing makes them easier to buy, but it doesn't change the fee or the odds of beating the market. For the full analysis, see active vs passive ETFs.

Where the money is going

Market share

How Australia's $388bn of ETF money is invested

Index and other ETFsActive ETFsComplex and geared
Money invested
80%17%
September new money
84%11%5%
Share of funds under management and of September 2026 net inflows. Active means funds named Active. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.

At 31 October 2026, Australians held about $388 billion in exchange traded products and added a net $6.9 billion in September alone. Active ETFs hold about 17% of that money, but took only about 11% of the new money. The bulk is flowing to low-cost index funds such as VAS, VGS, IOZ and A200, the four most popular ETFs that month.

Other differences worth knowing

  • Trading spread. When you buy an ETF you pay a small gap between the buying and selling price. For big index ETFs like VAS and VGS it is about 0.02%. For smaller active ETFs it can be 0.2% to 0.5% or more.
  • Tax. In both structures you pay tax on distributions and on capital gains when you sell. Assets held over 12 months get a 50% capital gains discount for individuals. Unlisted funds can also pass on gains when other investors withdraw; ETFs are generally less exposed to that, because units are mostly traded between investors on the exchange.
  • Regular investing. Unlisted funds often allow small automatic contributions with no brokerage. With ETFs, each purchase costs brokerage, so small, frequent buys can add up.
  • Behaviour. Live prices make ETFs easy to trade. That is a benefit, but it also makes it easier to sell in a panic.

Which suits you?

  • Index ETFs suit most investors who have a broker account and want low fees, daily transparency and the freedom to buy or sell any trading day.
  • Unlisted index funds suit investors who prefer automatic regular contributions without brokerage, or invest through a platform or super fund.
  • Active funds, listed or not, suit investors who have a strong reason to back a particular manager and accept the higher fee and the risk of trailing the market.

See our pick of the best ETFs in each category → or browse every low-cost ETF and active ETF. New to it all? Start with how to buy ETFs in Australia.

Common questions

Is an ETF the same as an index fund?

Not exactly. Most ETFs are index funds, but an ETF is defined by being listed on an exchange. Index funds can also be unlisted, and some ETFs are actively managed.

Are ETFs cheaper than managed funds?

Index ETFs usually are. Core funds such as A200 and IVV charge 0.04% a year. Active funds charge more whether listed or not: the median active ETF charges 0.70%.

What is the minimum investment for an ETF?

On the ASX, your first purchase of any ETF must be at least $500, plus brokerage. After that you can buy smaller amounts of the same fund.

Should I move my managed fund into ETFs?

It depends on the fees you pay now, your tax position and how you like to invest. Selling can trigger capital gains tax, so compare the long-term fee saving with the cost of switching first.

Joshua Stega

Joshua Stega is a financial adviser with 20 years' experience and the founder of ETF Adviser. He built ReviewETF to make every Australian ETF easy to find and compare.

General information only. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider the PDS and TMD before investing. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Data as at 31 October 2026.

Keep in touch with the markets

Get Joshua's weekly ETF research, trade alerts and the model portfolio. Free for 30 days.

Start your free trial

Keep reading