To 30 September 2026, global shares beat Australian shares over one, three and five years. VGS returned 11.8% a year over five years against 6.9% for A200. The main reason is what each market holds: the ASX is about 59% banks and miners, while global markets are led by technology. Australian shares still bring franking credits and no currency risk, so most investors hold both. The real question is the split.
What our data covers
Australia's oldest ETFs have been around a long time. STW listed in 2001, IVV and IOO in 2007, and VAS in 2009. The monthly TMX report we use, though, gives total returns over one, three and five years. So rather than reach back further with figures we can't verify, this guide uses those three periods, all to 30 September 2026, with distributions reinvested.
Five years is long enough to include the 2022 sell-off, a sharp rise in interest rates and the recent technology boom, so it is a fair test. It is still only one stretch of history, and the leadership between markets has swapped before.
The scoreboard
| ETF | Market | 1 year | 3 years (a year) | 5 years (a year) | Listed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A200 | ASX 200 | +2.9% | +11.0% | +6.9% | 2018 |
| VAS | ASX 300 | +2.2% | +10.8% | +6.5% | 2009 |
| STW | ASX 200 | +2.6% | +11.0% | +6.7% | 2001 |
| VGS | Developed world ex Australia | +10.1% | +17.9% | +11.8% | 2014 |
| IVV | US S&P 500 | +10.1% | +19.2% | +13.4% | 2007 |
| IOO | Global 100 largest | +15.6% | +22.9% | +16.4% | 2007 |
| VEU | World ex US | +14.0% | +16.5% | +9.2% | 2009 |
Total returns including distributions to 30 September 2026. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.
What $10,000 grew to over five years
$10,000 in A200 five years ago is now about $13,990. The same amount in VGS is about $17,460, and in IVV about $18,780. That gap of $3,500 to $4,800 on every $10,000 is large.
It isn't just the big funds. Across all 51 Australian share ETFs with a five-year record, the median return was 32.9%. Across 103 international share ETFs, it was 52.8%.
Median return: Australian vs international share ETFs
Why the two markets are so different
The ASX and the world share market look nothing alike. Buy an ASX 200 fund and more than half your money goes to banks and miners. Buy a global fund and almost a third goes to technology.
Where your money goes: A200 vs VGS
- Australia is a banks-and-miners market. Financials are about 35% of A200 and materials 24%. BHP and Commonwealth Bank alone are more than 21%.
- Global markets are led by technology. In VGS, Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft and Alphabet together are about 19% of the fund. Technology is only 1.9% of A200.
- So the result reflects a sector bet. The last five years rewarded large technology companies. When banks and commodities lead instead, Australia can come out ahead, as it has in some past periods.
It also explains why global funds differ among themselves. IOO, which holds the 100 largest global companies and is about 47% technology, did best. VEU, which leaves out the US, returned 9.2% a year over five years: behind VGS, but still ahead of Australia.
Not every Australian fund lagged
Australian income funds held up much better. VHY, Vanguard's high-yield fund, returned 10.2% a year over five years and 12.0% over the past year, ahead of VGS over that year. Energy and bank shares, which it holds more of, did well. That's a reminder that even within Australia, what you own matters. See our guide to high dividend ETFs.
What Australian shares still do well
- Franking credits. Australian companies pay tax before paying dividends, and investors get a credit for it. For a retiree or an SMSF in pension phase paying no tax, unused credits are refunded in cash, which adds noticeably to income.
- No currency risk. Your returns are in Australian dollars. Global shares rise and fall with the currency too, which can help or hurt.
- Familiarity and income. Australian shares have generally paid higher dividends than global shares, which suits investors who live off distributions.
How the split changes the result
Here is what a simple VAS and VGS portfolio returned over five years at different splits, with no rebalancing.
VAS and VGS: 5-year return at different splits
Many Australian investors and super funds land between 30% and 50% in Australian shares. Retirees who rely on franked income often sit at the higher end; younger investors focused on growth often hold less. Whichever you choose, a low-cost fund on each side keeps it simple. Compare VAS vs VGS or A200 vs BGBL.
Compare A200, VGS and IVV side by side →
Common questions
Have global shares beaten Australian shares?
Over the past one, three and five years, yes. To 30 September 2026, VGS returned 11.8% a year over five years against 6.9% for A200. Leadership between markets changes over time, so this is not a guarantee.
What percentage of my portfolio should be Australian shares?
There is no single right answer. Australia is about 2% of world markets, but many Australian investors hold 30 to 50% at home for franking credits and to avoid currency risk. It depends on your income needs and tax position.
Why has the ASX underperformed?
Mostly because of its sector mix. The ASX 200 is about 59% financials and materials and under 2% technology, and technology companies drove much of global returns over the past five years.
Are franking credits worth it?
They add real value, especially for retirees and SMSFs in pension phase who can receive unused credits as a cash refund. They help after-tax income but do not by themselves close the gap in total returns seen over the past five years.

Joshua Stega is a financial adviser with 20 years' experience and the founder of ETF Adviser. He built ReviewETF to make every Australian ETF easy to find and compare.
General information only. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider the PDS and TMD before investing. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Data as at 30 September 2026.