VGS and BGBL hold almost the same global companies and have returned within 1% a year of each other. BGBL charges 0.08% a year against 0.18% for VGS, and over three years it returned 18.7% a year vs 17.9%. VGS is more than three times larger and has a track record back to 2014. For new money the fee gap favours BGBL; for existing VGS holders, switching rarely pays once tax is counted.
Why this comparison matters
Most Australian investors hold a global shares ETF next to an Australian one, because Australia is only a small slice of the world's share market. VGS has been the default choice for a decade. At 30 September 2026 it managed $18.7 billion and took in $532 million in September alone, more than any other ETF in Australia.
BGBL arrived in May 2023 as a cheaper rival. It has grown quickly to $5.5 billion and was the fifth most popular ETF in September, with $220 million of new money.
The side-by-side numbers
| VGS | BGBL | |
|---|---|---|
| Issuer | Vanguard | Betashares |
| Index | MSCI World ex Australia | Solactive GBS Developed Markets ex Australia Large & Mid Cap |
| Fee (MER) | 0.18% | 0.08% |
| Fund size | $18.7bn | $5.5bn |
| September inflows | $532m | $220m |
| 1-year return | +10.1% | +10.4% |
| 3-year return (a year) | +17.9% | +18.7% |
| 5-year return (a year) | +11.8% | n/a (too new) |
| Listed | 2014 | 2023 |
Total returns including distributions to 30 September 2026. Source: TMX Australia monthly funds report.
VGS vs BGBL at a glance
What $10,000 grew to
Over three years, $10,000 in BGBL grew to about $16,740 vs $16,410 in VGS, a gap of around $330. The fee difference explains only part of that, roughly $40 to $50. Most of the rest comes from small differences between the two indices, which can just as easily go the other way in future.
The fee gap, in dollars
The difference is 0.10% a year. On $100,000 that is $180 a year for VGS and $80 for BGBL. It sounds small, but it repeats every year and compounds.
What fees cost on $100,000 over 20 years
Over 20 years the gap is about $7,000 on every $100,000. For an SMSF with $500,000 in global shares, that is about $35,000 over two decades, from fees alone.
How much do they overlap?
Based on each issuer's published holdings, the largest 400 positions of VGS and BGBL share 360 companies, and at least 76% of the money is in the same shares at the same weights. Both funds hold well over 1,000 companies, and the smaller ones in the tail overlap too, so the true figure is higher.
The same five giants lead both funds
- Sectors: technology is about 30% of VGS and 29% of BGBL; financials about 12% of each.
- Countries: the US is about two thirds of both, followed by Japan, the UK and Canada. BGBL holds slightly more in the US.
- Holding both adds a second fee and almost no diversification.
What about IWLD?
IWLD from iShares is often listed as the third low-cost option, at 0.09%. It now follows an ESG version of the MSCI World ex Australia index, which leaves out some companies on environmental and social grounds. As a result it overlaps only about 41% with VGS, and its top holdings are more concentrated: Nvidia is about 10.6% of the fund. Its five-year return of 78.6% is slightly ahead of VGS, but it is a different fund now, not a cheaper copy. See VGS vs IWLD.
Hedged versions
Both providers offer a currency hedged twin: VGAD at 0.21% and HGBL at 0.11%. Over the past year, as the Australian dollar strengthened, the hedged versions returned about 17%, around 7 points more than the unhedged funds. Over five years VGS beat VGAD. The same 0.10% fee gap applies. Read more in hedged vs unhedged ETFs or compare BGBL vs HGBL.
Which one should you choose?
- BGBL suits investors putting in new money who want the lowest fee for broad developed-market shares.
- VGS suits investors who value a long track record, the largest fund and the widely used MSCI World index.
- Already own VGS? Selling to switch can trigger capital gains tax. On a large unrealised gain, the tax bill can outweigh many years of fee savings. A common approach is to keep existing VGS and direct new contributions to BGBL.
- In pension phase? If your SMSF pays no tax on capital gains, switching costs are mainly brokerage and the trading spread, so the maths can be quite different. Check with your accountant or adviser.
Neither fund includes emerging markets such as China or India. If you want those, they need a separate fund. Compare VGS with the US-only IVV, or see the full VGS vs BGBL comparison page.
Common questions
Is BGBL better than VGS?
BGBL is cheaper (0.08% vs 0.18%) and has returned slightly more over one and three years to 30 September 2026. VGS is larger and has a longer track record. They hold almost the same companies, so the fee is the main difference.
Should I switch from VGS to BGBL?
Not necessarily. Selling can trigger capital gains tax and brokerage that outweigh years of fee savings. Many investors keep their existing VGS and put new money into BGBL.
Should I hold VGS and BGBL together?
Usually there is little point. They overlap heavily, so holding both gives you two fees for essentially the same portfolio.
Do VGS and BGBL include Australian shares?
No. Both exclude Australia, so they are designed to sit alongside an Australian shares ETF such as VAS or A200.

Joshua Stega is a financial adviser with 20 years' experience and the founder of ETF Adviser. He built ReviewETF to make every Australian ETF easy to find and compare.
General information only. It does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider the PDS and TMD before investing. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Data as at 30 September 2026.